Gallery: Player Ratings – Manchester City 4-3 Tottenham Hotspur

Tottenham Hotspur Stadium
Dom Le Roy

Lloris – 6

Picture 1 of 12

He did let in four goals! At fault for the third and perhaps none of the others. Some fine saves, one especially. Since he lost confidence in judging when to come for the ball perhaps he doesn’t give security and authority to the defenders in front of him as he once did.

Match Summary

This night is already up there as one of the most dramatic in Spurs history but it is also up there in achievement. This is the furthest Spurs have ever been in Europe’s premier competition.

You just have to have watched Maurizio Pochettino’s reaction (and I think the reaction he directed towards Daniel Levy) to know how much winning in this competition means to him.

Will this also go down as the most characterful run in the competition’s history? Spurs should never have made it this far, never got out of the mini league stage, never triumphed in this semi final. And yet they did. This wasn’t about flair, skill or even playing well. It was a bloody minded refusal to know they should have been beaten.

There’s a joy to be had in this game for the neutral, for the student of high drama, but I can’t go there. I didn’t want the drama. Even in that last minute – to think we’d done all of that only for it to be snatched away and then gifted back!

Our defence, for so long exemplary, chose this night to crumble like stale bread. In midfield without Winks, Sissoko, Dier, Dembele – two complete midfields – we were woefully short. And yet, we kept refusing the logic of the night. From two minutes in, the script of City sweeping to justified victory was being written. Our spear carriers and bit-part players just kept getting in the way.

How to rate the players? The following judgements are woefully inadequate. I could slate several of the individual contributions throughout the game, perhaps I will. But these churlish remarks have to be set against the character and the achievement. I do ask myself why bother assessing this performance in these pure terms. They’re all ten in any other analysis.

Have something to tell us about this article?


  1. Considering our players were all so much rubbish, how did we manage to progress to the semi finals of Europes biggest competition at the home of one of the richest clubs in the world?

  2. Who does these player ratings? Not the first time they appear plucked out of thin air. The player summaries are astonishing, if you’re going to run a “football” site get someone in who knows something about football.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.