Opinion: What is the point of Giovani Lo Celso at Tottenham?

Giovani Lo Celso
Catherine Ivill/Getty Images

Tottenham fans, I have a simple question… What is the point of have Giovani Lo Celso in this squad?

I mean that genuinely. What is one attribute he brings to the team that we are in desperate need for?

Originally, he was brought in to be the Eriksen replacement, despite what people may suggest. He was supposed to become our creative engine in the middle of the pitch and to relieve some of the workload.

We were so confident that he would be the creative playmaker we needed that we passed up on Bruno Fernandes for him.

However, once he arrived, it was quickly apparent that this would not be the case. Specifically, he is not even a number 10, with very little characteristics that would allow him to be successful in the role.

This is not criticism, many players come to a new club and their roles switch depending on the league, their adaptability and skillset.

So, Gio quickly switched from a number 10, to a player that would play a deeper role linking the play between the defense and attack. My simple question is, how has that gone?

As Spurs fans, after three years in the league, so we actually believe that Gio enhances this team when he plays? Do we miss his creativity when he is not in the squad?

My answer is, no. He has been a massive flop for this club and it is time we collectively admit it. Gio Lo Celso has been getting a pass from our supporters for too long and if he does not show improvement soon it begs the question, why does he keep getting chances?

Let’s dive into the numbers, all of which I pulled from the Premier League website. You know who gets relentless criticism from our fan base and no one speaks out? Harry Winks. Let’s compare their stats.

Since Gio’s arrival, Lo Celso and Winks have played 49 and 48 games respectively. In that time, Gio has scored one Premier League goal and Winks has yet to score. Gio has provided three Premier League assists to Wink’s zero.

This is not to say Winks should start over Gio, but to show that a player that fans almost universally say should not be at this club is barely being outplayed by a player we brought in three years ago to be our creative link.

Let’s dig deeper and see how they move the team forward, since they play similar roles on the pitch. In three seasons, Gio has had 4 big chances created to Wink’s 1. However, what I find most damning is his passing.

Gio has completed 1580 passes compared to Wink’s 2398. Their pass completion is 83% to 88%. Skeptics would say that this is due to Wink’s frustrating preference to pass backwards or sideways, a fair criticism of the player.

However, out of those 2398 passes, Winks has 266 backwards passes compared to Gio’s 249! Winks has almost 1000 more passes and only 17 more backwards passes.

This is followed up with Gio having 479 forward passes compared to Wink’s 714 with the former being dispossessed 48 times compared to Wink’s 19.

The numbers tell a story, Gio is average at best. He offers absolutely NOTHING for this team moving forward and we should not in any way rely on him.

The cherry on top is he has been injured for 38 games since his arrival, only 11 less games than he has played in the premier league.

If our fans think its time to for some accountability, I think I know where to start. The holiday is over for Lo Celso, it’s time for him to show up or get out of this club.

Have something to tell us about this article?


  1. Very true. He did well in Spain. He has had a lot of injuries. Plenty of time with us to settle, get used to our league. He has to deliver this year or be sold. I don’t think he is going to be a success. I hate his diving/hold his face nature when barely touched. He’s a very frustrating guy and I’m sure managers don’t know where to play him. Lamela has gone to Spain and thriving now. Do these guys play better/are happier in hot countries? De Maria was obviously a huge flop at Man Utd. Done well elsewhere.

  2. I agree 100%. I have always Lo Celso’s impact but his contributions are now zero. Gil might be young but from what we have seen I think he would create a lot more than Lo Celso. The other swap I would like to see is Rodon for Dier. Dier was a good defensive midfielder when he joined Spurs but he not a centre back. Rodon would be a much safer option.

  3. Gio de celso has been a huge disappointment and spurs should try to unload him in the next transfer window also ndombele very skilful better suited to Italian football doesn’t work hard enough reguillon also been very inconsistent give sessegnon a game when he’s fit lots of players brought in just havnt hit it off and I blame these football directors getting big wages and not studying players correctly


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.