Pundit defends Poch, claims he is right about top four being more important than trophies


Tottenham Hotspur’s hopes of winning a first domestic cup in nearly eleven years came to a crashing end in the space of four days.

Manager Mauricio Pochettino was heavily criticised over his team selection after Spurs’ 2-0 FA Cup defeat to Crystal Palace on Sunday.

The Argentine had made seven changes and handed starts to the likes of Georges-Kevin Nkoudou, Kyle Walker-Peters, and Oliver Skipp.

Pochettino came out fighting in his post-match press conference and said that he had no choice but to make wholesale changes given that Spurs have a Premier League game against Watford coming up tomorrow evening

He also claimed that finishing in the top 4 was more important for the club’s progress than winning a cup competition. This statement certainly didn’t sit well with many experts and pundits, who accused the 46-year-old of having his priorities all wrong.

However, ESPN’s senior football writer and expert Gabriele Marcotti has leaped to Pochettino’s defence and insisted that the Argentine was right to rest players against Palace.

In his column, Marcotti wrote: “You can’t really accuse Pochettino of snubbing cup competitions when, 72 hours earlier, his team were only knocked out of a League Cup semifinal on penalties. Or when they reached the semifinal of the FA Cup in the past two seasons. Right now, this is a team without Dele Alli, Harry Kane and Heung-Min Son, with Chelsea four points back (and with a trip to Stamford Bridge later this month) and Manchester United behind them winning eight in a row.

“In two weeks, Tottenham have a round of 16 game against Borussia Dortmund in the Champions League. But you want Pochettino to treat Palace away like a World Cup final? No? Then what? You want him to come out with lies and platitudes and nonsense instead?”

Marcotti also suggested that judging Pochettino on his failure to win a knockout cup competition is rather unfair given how far he has taken Tottenham.

He added: “Pochettino spoke the truth. The last Tottenham manager to win a trophy was Juande Ramos. Boy, that really moved the needle in the club’s history, didn’t it?”

“Oh, and by the way, the old trope whereby Pochettino can’t be any good because he hasn’t won anything is nonsense, too. You don’t judge managers who are so under-resourced, relative to the competition, based on a crapshoot like a knockout competition. You judge them on whether they out-perform their resources”

Have something to tell us about this article?


  1. Poch was right and this guy’s right, this looks like being our first decade without winning a trophy in many decades, but modern day football is about the present and the future. The injuries we’ve contended with this season would’ve been unthinkable at the beginning of the season, yet we’ve been defeated on penalties in a cup semi final, sit third in the premier league and have managed to rescue a progression from the jaws of knockout in the champions league with a result at the nou camp and other good fortune.

    So far we’ve lost Lloris, Aurier, Trippier, Vertonghen, Sanchez, Foyth, Rose, Davies, Dembele, Wanyama, Dier, Sissoko, Eriksen, Lamela, Moura, Alli, Kane and Son for lengthy spells and yet we still remain in 3rd. If you had said at the beginning of the season that we would have those injuries and have long spells with multiple injuries, who would predict we’d be top half, let alone 3rd.

    This is a season from hell in terms of injuries yet we are doing well. If getting out of the FA Cup freshens us up for the coming months and helps us stay injury free as we get our squad back then great decision because the players we have fit look a mix of jaded and sometimes inexperienced at the minute after a game nearly every 3 days since Chelsea 24th of November.

    A cup final victory is nice but it should never come at the expense of the overall project of growing as a club and competing with the best and most free spending club. The Deloitte money league released days ago and we are right behind Chelsea and Arsenal ,yet its not so long ago they had 3 and 4 times our revenue. That progress is massive and is what will ultimately drive our progress as a club, should we continue Avto outperform the opposition.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.